Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Giants ga-ga over Eli Manning, may trade up

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Giants ga-ga over Eli Manning, may trade up

    The Giants are giving serious consideration to moving up to the No. 1 overall pick in next month's draft to select Mississippi quarterback Eli Manning.

    Three sources familiar with the Giants situation said the team is convinced about Manning's potential as an NFL star and that the club is willing to trade with the Chargers, who have the first choice. The Giants have the fourth pick.

    It is not certain how the Giants would package a deal - whether they would trade away draft picks, players or a combination of both. No trade offer has been made, but talks could heat up at next week's NFL owners meetings in Palm Beach, Fla. If the Giants make a trade, it will not be at the expense of the team's future, according to a source with knowledge of their situation. In other words, don't expect a blockbuster. "It won't be a matter of selling the farm," the source said.

    If the Giants believe the Chargers are asking for too much in a trade, they would remain at No.4 and choose from Iowa tackle Robert Gallery, Miami (Ohio) quarterback Ben Roethlisberger or Pittsburgh receiver Larry Fitzgerald. There's also a chance they would consider USC sophomore receiver Mike Williams, who entered the draft after a judge ruled in favor of Ohio State sophomore running back Maurice Clarett by allowing him to enter the draft in spite of the NFL's eligibility rules.

    Several Giants coaches and front-office executives attended Manning's pro-day workout in New Orleans earlier this month, and all came away impressed. Giants general manager Ernie Accorsi, coach Tom Coughlin, offensive coordinator John Hufnagel, quarterbacks coach Kevin Gilbride and Giants scout Chris Mara made the trip.

    The Giants looked at Virginia quarterback Matt Schaub yesterday, and they're scheduled to meet with Roethlisberger today.

    Accorsi had no comment about any possible trade. "I'm not going to discuss anything we're considering before or during this draft," he said. "For anybody to read anything into that answer would be inaccurate."

    If the Giants do trade up, it would signal the eventual end to Kerry Collins' career with the team; the only uncertainty would be if the Giants keep him for the 2004 season, the final year of Collins' contract. The Giants have indicated they expect Collins to play this season, even if they draft a quarterback.

    The Chargers spent yesterday and today with Manning, who had an individual workout and intensive discussions with San Diego officials. Chargers GM A.J. Smith could not be reached for comment, but told Newsday in a recent interview that he had not had any discussions with the Giants - or any team - about a trade for the first overall choice.

    The Chargers are in somewhat of a quandary over what to do with the first pick, according to executives from other teams. They are still scarred by the Ryan Leaf fiasco in 1998, when they drafted him with the second overall choice after the Colts grabbed Eli's older brother Peyton Manning. Leaf turned into one of the biggest busts in NFL history. The last time the Chargers traded down from the No. 1 pick - in 2001 - they passed up on a chance to draft Michael Vick, who has shown star quality as the Falcons' quarterback.

    The Chargers are also looking at Roethlisberger and N.C. State quarterback Phillip Rivers. If the Giants don't get Manning or Roethlisberger, they will consider taking Rivers in the second round. Many scouts, however, believe Rivers' stock has risen in recent weeks and that he won't last that long.

    Cousin signed. The Giants signed Panthers free-agent cornerback Terry Cousin to a three- year deal believed to be worth $2.7 million. The contract includes a $900,000 signing bonus.


    Source: news day

  • #2
    Manning will be a great QB for so many reasons. He has a very good arm and is very accurate with terrfic QB mechanics. He has incredible football intelligence and poise. He can read and react to a defense. He has a great work ethic which should only help him to become an even better QB than he already is. He is a leader on the field and players will respect the way he plays the game. He has ideal size for a QB and has a quick release. He has played incredibly on a pretty mediocre team under enormous pressure to live up to not only his brother a few years before him, but his father 30 years before him at the same school. He led that mediocre team to a top 25 finish in an incredibly tough SEC conference. I hear a lot of people talk about bloodlines or say things like "just because his last name is Manning". I dont think we should understate what that means though. It means that this guy has been taught since he was very young how to be a QB. It means that any tutoring that he doesnt get from the staff of the team that he is playing for he can get from a future Hall of Fame brother or father. The last name alone is not a reason to draft him but when you add the type of intangibles that it brings that I stated above it only increases his overall value.

    You absolutely have to have a good defense to win Championships. The reasons that I could see taking Manning instead of say Gallery or Fitzgerald or anyone else would be that he is a very rare QB prospect. Of course you can win without having this type of QB but when you have the chance at a guy like this it is very tough to pass on him and sometimes when you do you regret it (Chargers traded Vick). The Chargers need blockers for LT to succeed and that is true, but a RB's best friend can also be a very good QB that defenses have to respect, especially if that QB is a master at play action pass which Eli does extremely well.

    The Chargers offensive line needs to be addressed also and that is the reason why I think Gallery has to also be given a lot of consideration. However, this post is why I think Eli would be a good #1 pick so I wont go into Gallery too much. I think an offensive line can be put together with a scheme that would make them work well together though. I think having LT and a great play action QB who has a quick release, reads the defense well and doesnt take a lot of sacks because of his pocket presence would instantly "improve" the play of the offensive line also. There is something to be said for a QB that come to the line of scrimmage and read what a defense is going to do before the ball is snapped. It makes everyone on the team a better player to have that on their side.

    Anyway, I can't wait to see what happens at the NFL draft time. The Chargers have a chance to get a star in Eli Manning. It will be interesting to see what they do with their pick. But I'm sure they're screw it up some how lol

    Comment

    Unconfigured Ad Widget

    Collapse
    Working...
    X